Research
PCOS vs. Hypothyroidism: Key Differences
Explore the differences between PCOS and hypothyroidism, their symptoms, causes, and treatment options to better understand these common hormonal disorders.
June 18, 2025
·
19
Explore the differences between PCOS and hypothyroidism, their symptoms, causes, and treatment options to better understand these common hormonal disorders.
PCOS (Polycystic Ovary Syndrome) and hypothyroidism are two hormonal disorders that often affect women and share overlapping symptoms like weight gain, fatigue, and irregular menstrual cycles. However, they have different causes, diagnostic methods, and treatments. Here’s a quick breakdown:
| Aspect | PCOS | Hypothyroidism |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Cause | Hormonal imbalance, insulin resistance | Underactive thyroid (low hormones) |
| Key Symptoms | Irregular periods, hirsutism, acne | Fatigue, cold sensitivity, dry skin |
| Diagnosis | Blood tests (androgens, glucose), ultrasound | TSH, T3, T4 blood tests |
| Treatment | Lifestyle changes, metformin, contraceptives | Levothyroxine (hormone replacement) |
Women with PCOS are 2.5 times more likely to develop thyroid issues, and 20%-22% of women with PCOS also have hypothyroidism. Regular screenings for thyroid function are essential for women with PCOS to ensure early detection and management of both conditions.
Polycystic Ovary Syndrome (PCOS) is a hormonal condition that affects women during their reproductive years. It gets its name from the possibility of ovarian cysts, though not all women with PCOS have them. This disorder disrupts normal ovarian function, leading to irregular ovulation and menstrual cycles, which can impact fertility. While PCOS often becomes noticeable in the late teens or early twenties, it can develop at any point during a woman’s reproductive years.
The underlying issue in PCOS is a significant hormonal imbalance that affects multiple systems in the body. Women with PCOS often have higher levels of hormones such as testosterone, estrogen, luteinizing hormone (LH), insulin, and anti-müllerian hormone. Elevated androgens, in particular, are a defining feature of PCOS. These hormones interfere with ovarian function, leading to irregular menstrual cycles and other symptoms.
Insulin resistance is another major factor in PCOS. Many women with the condition struggle to use insulin properly, which causes higher insulin levels in the bloodstream. This resistance not only increases the likelihood of developing type 2 diabetes but also worsens hormonal imbalances, amplifying PCOS symptoms.
PCOS symptoms can vary widely from person to person. Some women may only notice irregular periods or difficulty conceiving, while others experience a broader range of issues, including:
Globally, PCOS affects an estimated 6% to 13% of women of reproductive age. In the United States, a study by Kaiser Permanente Washington (2006–2019) found a PCOS prevalence rate of 5.2% in their patient population, nearly double the earlier U.S. estimate of 2.9% based on insurance data. The study also noted an overall incidence of 42.5 per 10,000 person-years.
Prevalence rates differ among ethnic groups. Hawaiian and Pacific Islander women had the highest rates at 7.6%, followed by Native American and Hispanic women. However, up to 70% of women with PCOS remain undiagnosed worldwide, meaning many women in the U.S. may be unaware they have the condition, missing out on early treatment opportunities.
Genetics play a significant role in PCOS. Women with a family history of PCOS or type 2 diabetes face a higher risk of developing the condition. While no single gene has been identified, PCOS often runs in families, suggesting multiple genetic factors are at play.
Obesity is both a risk factor for and a result of PCOS. Excess weight can worsen insulin resistance, intensifying symptoms, while hormonal imbalances linked to PCOS can make losing weight more difficult. Additionally, lifestyle factors like inactivity, poor diet, and chronic stress may contribute to the condition’s development and severity.
After this overview of PCOS, we’ll explore hypothyroidism to better understand how these two conditions differ.
Hypothyroidism, also known as underactive thyroid, happens when the thyroid gland doesn’t produce enough hormones. Since the thyroid plays a critical role in regulating energy use, its hormones affect nearly every organ in the body, including the heart. When hormone levels drop too low, many of your body’s processes slow down significantly.
This differs from PCOS, which mainly disrupts reproductive hormones and impacts fertility and ovarian function. Hypothyroidism, on the other hand, affects the body’s overall metabolic rate. Let’s dive into its causes, symptoms, and risk factors.
In the United States, the most common cause of hypothyroidism is Hashimoto’s disease, an autoimmune condition where the body’s immune system attacks the thyroid gland. Other causes include thyroiditis, thyroid surgery, radiation treatments, certain medications, and congenital defects. In rarer cases, factors like iodine imbalance or issues with the pituitary gland or hypothalamus can lead to hypothyroidism.
Globally, iodine deficiency remains the leading cause of hypothyroidism. However, this is rare in the U.S. thanks to the widespread use of iodized salt. Hypothyroidism is classified into two main types: primary hypothyroidism, where the thyroid itself is unable to produce enough hormones, and secondary hypothyroidism, where the thyroid is functional but doesn’t receive the proper signals from the pituitary gland or hypothalamus.
Symptoms of hypothyroidism tend to appear gradually, which often delays diagnosis. Since thyroid hormones are responsible for regulating energy use, most symptoms are tied to a slowing metabolism. Common signs include fatigue, weight gain, sensitivity to cold, joint and muscle pain, dry skin, thinning hair, and depression. Women may also experience heavy or irregular menstrual cycles and fertility challenges.
Other symptoms can include constipation, a slowed heart rate, puffiness in the face, a hoarse voice, and even carpal tunnel syndrome. Because these symptoms develop slowly, they’re often mistaken for stress, aging, or other conditions. As a result, many people don’t realize they have hypothyroidism until the symptoms become severe enough to interfere with daily life.
In the U.S., about 5% of people aged 12 and older are affected by hypothyroidism. Its prevalence has been increasing, with rates rising from 9.5% in 2012 to 11.7% in 2019, according to a retrospective study. Women are especially at risk - they are 5 to 8 times more likely to develop thyroid issues than men. In fact, one in eight women will develop a thyroid problem at some point in her life. Age also plays a role, with the condition becoming more common in people over 60.
Hashimoto’s disease specifically affects about 5 in 100 people in the U.S.. Women are 4 to 10 times more likely than men to develop this condition, which typically appears between the ages of 30 and 50. This overlaps with the age range when PCOS often becomes noticeable. Other risk factors include a family history of thyroid issues, autoimmune diseases like type 1 diabetes or lupus, recent pregnancy (within six months), and genetic conditions such as Turner syndrome.
The American Thyroid Association suggests screening for thyroid issues every five years starting at age 35, particularly for women with risk factors. Early detection is crucial because untreated hypothyroidism can lead to severe complications, including heart problems.
Distinguishing between PCOS and hypothyroidism can be tricky since both share overlapping symptoms. Recognizing these similarities and differences is crucial for accurate diagnosis and effective treatment.
PCOS and hypothyroidism share common symptoms like weight gain, fatigue, and mood changes, but they also have unique traits. For instance, PCOS is marked by elevated androgen levels, insulin resistance, and small ovarian cysts. These can lead to symptoms such as hirsutism (excessive hair growth on the face, chest, or back), acne, and irregular menstrual cycles. Many women with PCOS also experience thinning hair on the scalp.
Hypothyroidism, on the other hand, is caused by an underactive thyroid gland, which slows down the body's metabolism. In addition to shared symptoms, hypothyroidism often includes cold sensitivity, joint and muscle pain, dry skin, constipation, and a slowed heart rate. Unlike PCOS, women with hypothyroidism are more likely to experience heavy menstrual bleeding rather than irregular cycles.
The onset of symptoms can also differ. Hypothyroidism symptoms usually develop gradually over months or even years. In contrast, PCOS symptoms often emerge during puberty or early adulthood when hormonal changes are at their peak. Next, let’s explore how these conditions are diagnosed.
The diagnostic process for PCOS and hypothyroidism differs significantly, underscoring the need for a thorough evaluation.
To diagnose PCOS, doctors look for evidence of irregular ovulation, elevated androgen levels (confirmed through blood tests), and ovarian cysts visible on a pelvic ultrasound. Since PCOS is a diagnosis of exclusion, other conditions - including thyroid disorders - must be ruled out first.
For hypothyroidism, diagnosis relies on a combination of medical history, physical examination, and specific thyroid blood tests. Key tests include thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH), triiodothyronine (T3), and thyroxine (T4) levels. The table below highlights key differences and similarities in symptoms and diagnostic approaches.
| Aspect | PCOS | Hypothyroidism |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Symptoms | Irregular periods, hirsutism, acne, weight gain, fatigue | Weight gain, fatigue, cold sensitivity, dry skin, heavy periods |
| Shared Symptoms | Weight gain, fatigue, mood changes | Weight gain, fatigue, mood changes |
| Unique Symptoms | Male-pattern hair growth, scalp hair thinning, insulin resistance | Constipation, joint and muscle pain |
| Main Diagnostic Tests | Androgen levels, LH/FSH ratio, pelvic ultrasound, glucose tolerance test | TSH, T3, T4 blood tests |
| Additional Tests | Insulin levels, lipid panel, prolactin, AMH | Thyroid antibodies, thyroid ultrasound |
| Diagnostic Approach | Diagnosis of exclusion (rule out other conditions first) | Direct diagnosis through blood tests |
| Physical Exam | Hirsutism, acne, hair thinning | Thyroid gland examination, reflexes, heart rate |
Diagnosing both conditions simultaneously can be even more complex. Research shows that nearly 50% of women with PCOS also have a thyroid-related condition, such as thyroid dysfunction or positive thyroid antibodies. Symptoms of hypothyroidism often overlap with other disorders, so relying solely on symptoms for diagnosis isn't enough. Additionally, women with both PCOS and subclinical hypothyroidism often exhibit higher levels of LDL cholesterol.
Accurate diagnosis requires a systematic approach. Healthcare providers should always evaluate thyroid function when assessing patients with PCOS-like symptoms. Misdiagnosis is not uncommon because of the overlapping features and the absence of combined diagnostic criteria. A clear understanding of these distinctions lays the groundwork for effective treatment, which will be explored in the next section.
PCOS and hypothyroidism often share overlapping symptoms, making it tricky to differentiate between the two. However, their root causes are quite different. Understanding these triggers not only sheds light on why these conditions often coexist but also highlights why diagnosing them can be so challenging. Let’s break down the specific causes of each condition.
PCOS is influenced by a mix of genetic, hormonal, and environmental factors. Genetics play a particularly strong role, accounting for up to 72% of the risk of developing PCOS. If you have a family history of PCOS, type 2 diabetes, or other metabolic disorders, your chances of developing PCOS increase significantly.
One of the primary drivers of PCOS is insulin resistance. When the body’s cells don’t respond effectively to insulin, the pancreas compensates by producing even more insulin. This excess insulin can stimulate the ovaries to produce higher levels of testosterone, leading to symptoms like irregular menstrual cycles, excessive hair growth (hirsutism), and ovarian cysts.
Lifestyle factors also contribute to PCOS. Poor diet, obesity, and sedentary behavior can worsen insulin resistance, amplifying the hormonal imbalances tied to PCOS. Additionally, environmental exposures, such as endocrine-disrupting chemicals, and even conditions in the womb during fetal development, may increase the likelihood of developing PCOS later in life.
In the United States, the most common cause of hypothyroidism is Hashimoto’s thyroiditis, an autoimmune condition where the immune system attacks the thyroid gland, impairing its ability to produce hormones.
Genetics also play a significant role here, with over 70% of susceptibility to thyroid autoimmunity linked to inherited factors. Beyond genetics, age and gender are key risk factors - hypothyroidism is more common in women and those over 50.
Iodine deficiency is another major cause, particularly in areas where iodine intake is low or in cases of radiation exposure. Other triggers include thyroid surgery, viral infections, respiratory illnesses, and certain medications like lithium. Environmental factors, including exposure to endocrine-disrupting chemicals, can also interfere with normal thyroid function.
Now that we’ve explored the distinct causes of PCOS and hypothyroidism, let’s look at the risk factors they share.
Both PCOS and hypothyroidism share several overlapping risk factors, which can complicate diagnosis and treatment. For instance, a family history of autoimmune or metabolic disorders raises the likelihood of developing either condition.
Obesity is another major shared factor. It not only worsens insulin resistance in PCOS but also disrupts thyroid hormone metabolism, increasing inflammation and the likelihood of autoimmune responses.
Interestingly, elevated estrogen levels in women with PCOS may increase their risk of autoimmune thyroid conditions. Research shows that 22.8% of women with PCOS develop Hashimoto’s thyroiditis, compared to just 5.7% of women without PCOS. Another study from Eastern India reported that 22.5% of women with PCOS also had hypothyroidism, compared to 8.75% in women without PCOS.
Emerging research also points to gut health as a potential link. Poor gut microbiome balance, often influenced by diet and lifestyle, may trigger inflammation and autoimmune responses that negatively impact both ovarian and thyroid function.
Because of these shared risk factors, regular thyroid screenings are crucial for women with PCOS. Having both conditions can increase the risk of complications such as diabetes, obesity, cardiovascular issues, and fertility challenges. Identifying these connections is key to better managing and treating these conditions effectively.
Understanding the causes and risk factors of PCOS and hypothyroidism lays the groundwork for tailored treatment strategies. While hypothyroidism often involves straightforward hormone replacement, managing PCOS requires a more comprehensive approach that addresses multiple symptoms and underlying issues.
Managing PCOS typically involves a blend of medications and lifestyle changes. Commonly prescribed medications include:
Lifestyle changes play a critical role in PCOS management. A diet rich in low-GI foods (like whole grains, legumes, and non-starchy vegetables) and omega-3 sources (such as walnuts, chia seeds, and fatty fish) can improve insulin sensitivity and reduce inflammation. Regular physical activity, with at least 120 minutes of vigorous exercise per week, is also recommended.
"Health optimization in people with PCOS is sensitive to a lot of things - especially the things we eat and drink, our sleep-wake cycle, and physical activity." – Shruthi Mahalingaiah, MD, MS, Obstetrician and Gynecologist, Mass General Brigham
In contrast, hypothyroidism treatment focuses on hormone replacement to address metabolic imbalances. The cornerstone of treatment is levothyroxine, which restores normal metabolic function and balances TSH levels. Regular blood tests are essential to ensure proper dosing, with TSH levels typically maintained between 0.4 and 4.0 mIU/L.
Dietary adjustments can also support thyroid health. Foods rich in iodine (like iodized salt, fish, and seaweed), selenium, and zinc (found in Brazil nuts, seafood, and beans) are particularly beneficial. A balanced diet that includes proteins, healthy fats, and complex carbohydrates can help alleviate symptoms like constipation and weight gain.
| Aspect | PCOS | Hypothyroidism |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Medications | Oral contraceptives, metformin, spironolactone, eflornithine | Levothyroxine |
| Treatment Goals | Regulate menstrual cycles, reduce hirsutism, manage insulin resistance | Restore normal T4 levels and relieve symptoms |
| Monitoring Requirements | Hormonal and metabolic markers | TSH levels (0.4–4.0 mIU/L) |
| Dietary Focus | Low-GI foods, anti-inflammatory nutrients, insulin management | Iodine, selenium, zinc, balanced macronutrients |
| Exercise Recommendations | At least 120 minutes of vigorous exercise weekly | General fitness for overall health |
| Treatment Complexity | Multi-targeted approach for various symptoms | Single hormone replacement therapy |
When PCOS and hypothyroidism occur together, coordinated treatment is essential. Monitoring both metabolic and thyroid functions becomes critical due to overlapping symptoms. Interestingly, women with PCOS are significantly more likely to develop autoimmune thyroiditis, with a fivefold increased risk compared to those without PCOS (odds ratio 4.81, 95% confidence interval 2.88–8.04).
"If you are diagnosed with polycystic ovary syndrome, it doesn't mean that you are destined to have poor health. There is a lot you can do to take charge, minimize symptoms and keep yourself healthy." – Amanda Stathos, M.S., R.D., L.D.N., Clinical Dietitian at Johns Hopkins' Sibley Memorial Hospital
For more in-depth guidance on managing PCOS, including specific medication and lifestyle strategies, PCOSHelp provides clinically supported resources designed to empower women in navigating their treatment options.
When it comes to PCOS and hypothyroidism, the overlapping symptoms can make diagnosis tricky. Both conditions impact the endocrine system, and their shared effects often blur the lines between the two.
PCOS and hypothyroidism share several symptoms, including weight gain that resists typical diet and exercise, irregular menstrual cycles, fertility difficulties, fatigue, and depression. These commonalities can make it challenging to pinpoint the root cause without further investigation.
Despite their similarities, there are key differences that help set these conditions apart. For instance:
If hirsutism accompanies irregular cycles, PCOS is usually the more likely culprit.
The diagnostic process also reflects these differences. Hypothyroidism can be identified with a blood test measuring TSH and thyroid hormone levels. Diagnosing PCOS, however, is more complex - it involves ruling out other conditions, including thyroid disorders. Additionally, if hypothyroidism symptoms persist despite levothyroxine treatment, it could suggest the presence of both conditions.
Interestingly, research indicates that 20%–22% of women with PCOS also have hypothyroidism or Hashimoto's thyroiditis, with women with PCOS being 2.5 times more likely to develop thyroid issues. When these conditions coexist, the risks for diabetes, obesity, cardiovascular disease, and pregnancy complications increase significantly.
This connection highlights the importance of regular thyroid screenings for individuals with PCOS. Similarly, if you have hypothyroidism and notice symptoms like hirsutism or ongoing irregular periods despite treatment, it may be time to evaluate for PCOS. Recognizing these nuances is crucial for accurate diagnosis and effective management, setting the stage for the next steps discussed in the following section.
Both PCOS and hypothyroidism can pose serious health risks if left untreated. Understanding these risks highlights the importance of accurate diagnosis and timely treatment to maintain long-term health.
PCOS isn’t just a reproductive issue - it can lead to a range of long-term health problems. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, "PCOS is a lifelong health condition that continues far beyond a woman's childbearing years".
One of the most prominent effects of PCOS is its impact on fertility. Studies show that up to 85% of individuals with PCOS experience anovulation, making it a leading cause of infertility. In the U.S., PCOS affects 6% to 12% of women of reproductive age.
Another major concern is the increased risk of type 2 diabetes. Insulin resistance, a hallmark of PCOS, often leads to prediabetes or diabetes earlier in life compared to those without the condition.
Heart health is also at risk. Women with untreated PCOS face a higher likelihood of developing cardiovascular issues, including high blood pressure and stroke, as they age.
Untreated hypothyroidism can result in a range of serious complications. Heart disease is a major concern, as low thyroid hormone levels can disrupt heart rhythm, elevate blood pressure, and raise cholesterol.
Cognitive issues such as memory loss and brain fog are also common in untreated cases, potentially affecting daily life and long-term mental health.
Peripheral neuropathy, which causes numbness, tingling, and pain in the extremities, may develop and become irreversible without proper treatment.
The most severe consequence of untreated hypothyroidism is myxedema, a rare but life-threatening condition. Myxedema has a mortality rate of 20% to 60% even with intensive care.
Fertility challenges are another concern, as thyroid hormones are crucial for ovulation and maintaining a healthy pregnancy.
When PCOS and hypothyroidism occur together, the health risks are amplified. These overlapping conditions often mask each other, making it harder to identify the full extent of the problem. Research shows that having both conditions increases reproductive and metabolic risks. For example, women with PCOS and subclinical hypothyroidism have been found to have higher triglyceride levels, elevated fasting insulin, and greater insulin resistance.
Fertility issues can also escalate. Thyroid dysfunction can worsen PCOS-related reproductive challenges, leading to higher rates of infertility and complications during pregnancy.
Managing both conditions simultaneously adds another layer of complexity. Healthcare providers need to coordinate treatments carefully to address the unique challenges posed by each disorder. Regular thyroid screenings are strongly recommended for individuals with PCOS, as studies indicate that women with PCOS are 2.5 times more likely to develop thyroid disease.
Early diagnosis and a well-coordinated treatment plan can significantly reduce these combined risks.
Distinguishing between PCOS and hypothyroidism is crucial because, while they share symptoms like weight gain, fatigue, and irregular periods, their root causes and treatments differ significantly.
PCOS, short for polycystic ovary syndrome, is marked by higher androgen levels, insulin resistance, and ovarian cysts. It affects about 6% to 13% of reproductive-aged women in the U.S., with many cases going undiagnosed. Common treatments include oral contraceptives, metformin, and lifestyle changes. On the other hand, hypothyroidism results from the thyroid gland not producing enough hormones, often due to autoimmune conditions like Hashimoto’s thyroiditis. This condition is diagnosed through thyroid blood tests and typically managed with levothyroxine.
Research underscores the connection between the two conditions: Women with PCOS are 2.5 times more likely to develop thyroid disease. Hashimoto’s thyroiditis has been found in 22.8% of women with PCOS compared to 5.7% in those without it. A Turkish study even reported a prevalence of 38.18% among PCOS patients.
When these conditions coexist, they can lead to more severe metabolic challenges, increasing the risks of cardiovascular disease and diabetes. Accurate diagnosis is key to effective treatment. For women with PCOS, regular thyroid screenings are critical. Testing for TSH, free T4, free T3, and thyroid antibodies provides a comprehensive evaluation.
For more in-depth advice on managing PCOS and hypothyroidism, check out PCOSHelp.
Distinguishing between PCOS and hypothyroidism can be tricky because some symptoms overlap, but there are clear differences to keep in mind. PCOS is often associated with irregular periods, higher androgen levels (which can lead to excess facial or body hair), ovarian cysts, and challenges with fertility. On the other hand, hypothyroidism usually comes with fatigue, weight gain, dry skin, thinning hair, and sensitivity to cold.
Because symptoms like weight gain and irregular periods can show up in both conditions, doctors often rely on blood tests to measure thyroid hormone levels and androgen levels. In some instances, both conditions might occur together, making it even more important to have a thorough evaluation by a healthcare provider to ensure the right diagnosis and treatment.
Regular thyroid checkups are a key step for women with PCOS, as thyroid disorders - especially hypothyroidism - often go hand in hand with this condition. When these two occur together, they can worsen issues like irregular menstrual cycles, weight gain, and hormonal imbalances.
Catching thyroid problems early makes it easier to manage PCOS symptoms and lowers the risk of further health complications. Keeping a close eye on thyroid function ensures any changes are dealt with quickly, helping to maintain overall health and improve treatment outcomes.
Managing PCOS and hypothyroidism becomes more manageable with a few thoughtful lifestyle changes. Start with a balanced diet that features low glycemic index foods, lean proteins, healthy fats, and anti-inflammatory ingredients. These choices can help tackle insulin resistance and reduce inflammation.
Adding regular exercise to your routine is another game-changer. Activities like moderate aerobic workouts and resistance training can boost insulin sensitivity, aid in weight management, and support better metabolic health.
Don't overlook the importance of stress management and adequate sleep, as both play a big role in keeping symptoms in check. And, of course, staying consistent with prescribed medications is key. Together, these adjustments can make a noticeable difference in how you feel and improve your overall well-being.
